jill.
All Notes
Positioning · By Jill Brines

5 Product Positioning Mistakes First-Time Founders Can Fix

If people don't understand what you built, start with the audience, problem and alternative—not another homepage rewrite.

Product positioning is how you explain who your product is for, what problem it solves, and why that person would choose it over the alternatives. Messaging turns those decisions into the words on your page. When the decisions are fuzzy, rewriting the words can become a very time-consuming way to stay stuck. Here are five places I would look first.

1. Defining the audience as ‘anyone who needs this’

A product can eventually serve several groups. Your first launch message still needs a clear person in mind. Otherwise, every sentence has to be broad enough to include everyone—and specific enough to persuade no one.

Pick one starting audience and describe the moment they feel the problem. Ask whether your examples, language and invitation make sense to that person. You can expand later; this is a starting point, not a permanent exclusion.

2. Leading with features instead of the problem

A dashboard, automation or calendar is a feature. The reason someone wants it is what that feature helps them change. Don't make a visitor translate the feature list into a benefit by themselves.

For each feature, finish this sentence: ‘This helps you ___.’ Then check that the claim is actually true of the product today. Use the clearest outcome in your main explanation and keep supporting features underneath.

3. Ignoring what people do instead

Your alternative isn't always another app. It might be a spreadsheet, a notebook, a shared message thread, or doing nothing. That current habit has advantages, even if it looks messy to you.

Ask what your customer likes about their existing approach and where it fails them. Your positioning needs to explain a reason to switch, not just a reason your product exists.

4. Using a clever headline without a clear explanation

I like a good line. I don't like making people solve a riddle before they understand the offer. Keep the personality, then give it a plain-language explanation nearby.

Read your headline and first paragraph to someone who doesn't know your product. Ask them who it helps and what it does. Don't explain the answer first—that would hide the very confusion you're trying to find.

5. Changing the message before checking the evidence

A quiet launch doesn't automatically mean your positioning is wrong. Perhaps the right people haven't seen it, the page is difficult to use, or the next step asks for too much too soon.

Separate those questions. Record who saw the offer, what they understood, what they asked, and whether they acted. Make one meaningful change at a time so you have a chance to learn what helped.

  • Can an intended customer explain the product back to me?
  • Does the message match what the product does today?
  • Is the next step easy to find and complete?
  • Am I learning from relevant people, not only friends?

A clearer next move.

If you keep rewriting your homepage without getting clearer, a Launch Teardown gives you an outside review of your landing page, offer and plan. I deliver five prioritized fixes—not a new pile of vague opinions.

Find Your Launch Support